Zoom for Education has been adopted by thousands of schools nationwide. Zoom began marketing to K-12 schools in November 2019, prior to the Covid pandemic. Zoom also created a website specific for education: https://zoom.us/education. Zoom has referred to its education platform as a Zoom for K-12 service but apparently rather than face data privacy and transparency requirements for contracted school service providers in Colorado law, Zoom NOW claims they are not a school service. More on this below, but first we’ll focus on Zoom’s third party data sharing and cookies.
“…there are still privacy issue areas where Zoom falls short, including its limited, but still targeted, use of advertising and third-party tracking that may affect students in K–12. (Ads don’t appear on Zoom itself but on other sites kids visit after using it.) “
Similarly, this March 17, 2020 New York Times article entitled We Live in Zoom Now, also warned about Zoom’s use of student data for advertising, quoting Jules Polenetsky, CEO of the Future of Privacy Forum, as saying,
“We only collect students’ Personal Information to provide the Zoom for K-12 service to the School Subscriber, not for marketing or advertising, and, with the limited exception of our service providers, we do not share Personal Information about K-12 students with other parties”
“… Zoom and/or our third-party service providers also automatically collect some information using methods such as cookies. Information automatically collected may include Internet protocol (IP) addresses, browser type, Internet service provider (ISP), operating system, and date/time stamp. We use this information to provide and support the Zoom for K-12 services. We do not use this information to deliver advertising or for any other purpose not related to the delivery and support of the services.”
Students under 16 CANNOT create Zoom accounts.
“Student Users are not permitted to create K-12 Accounts but may use the Services when invited to join a meeting hosted by a K-12 Account User. Although Zoom prohibits children and teens under the age of 16 from creating a Zoom account (and employs an online age screen to support this restriction), Student Users, even if under the age of 13, may join a meeting hosted by a K-12 Account User. School Subscribers are responsible for obtaining any parental consent necessary for use of the Services under their K-12 Accounts by Student Users, including children under the age 13.”
Hopefully K-12 schools, parents, and students are aware of this clear wording and will take heed. Apparently in their rush to virtual learning during the Covid 19 Spring shut down, some K-12 schools required students to download the Zoom App and create their own Zoom account- using their school email- in an effort to decrease Zoombombing. As EdSurge reported in March of 2020, “Students should never be making an account in Zoom,” “That’s where it can get districts into trouble.”
No more advertising or analytics.
When you click on the More Info link on the pop-up notice, Zoom for Education now automatically opts-out advertising cookies but that was not the case previously, as you can see from this April 2020 screen capture that shows ads were opted-in.
And here is a list of the Advertising Cookies on the Zoom for Education page that apparently prior to July 2020 were automatically opted-in, ( we underlined in red), and allowed cookies “to serve ads relevant to your interests” unless the user clicked the opt-out box.
Here are a few privacy and security Zoom issues in the news:
- Zoom falsely claiming data is end to end encrypted, Verge link
- Zoom sharing user data with Facebook, link
- Zoom sharing user data with LinkedIn, link
- Zoombombing and FBI warning, link
- Zoom routing data (with encryption keys) through China, link
- Over 500,000 Zoom accounts being sold on the dark web, link
- Zoom’s security issues were exposed over 2 years ago by Dropbox, this is not a new problem, link
- Class action lawsuit for unlawful eavesdropping, link
- NY, CT, FL Attorneys General investigate Zoom security practices
- NY resolved Zoom investigation: NY created this master agreement where Zoom must adhere to certain security requirements but agreement does not require Zoom to get consent or inform parents of when third parties access their children’s data, does not prohibit re-disclosure of data. The agreement does not address use of artificial intelligence, facial recognition, nor is Zoom required to tell parents how student data are analyzed or profiled.
- Maryland parents concerned about privacy, security of student data collected by Google and Zoom for Education, link
- Colorado Attorney General investigates Zoom for Education, link
- The Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC) filed a complaint with the FTC against Zoom in July 2019. “Zoom intentionally designed its web conferencing service to bypass browser security settings and remotely enable a user’s web camera without the knowledge or consent of the user.” link
So, is Zoom “safe” now?
Common Sense Media recently wrote this July 14, 2020 piece, Privacy Risks of the Top 5 Distance Learning Apps, which evaluated privacy features of Zoom, Apple Facetime, Microsoft Teams, Google Hangouts, and Cisco Webex.
Common Sense gave Zoom the highest overall privacy rating.
In looking at Common Sense Media’s Privacy Evaluation of Zoom for Education, you can see they say that Zoom is clearly being marketed as a School Purpose and intended for students, “primarily used by, designed for, and marketed toward students in grades preK–12.”
Common Sense Media gave Zoom for Education a high rating for privacy even though they admit to the following uncertainties:
- User information can be transferred to a third party.
- Unclear whether users are notified if their information is transferred to a third party.
- Unclear whether user information can be deleted prior to its transfer to a third party
- Unclear whether the vendor describes their deidentification process of user information.
- Unclear whether data are shared for research and/or product improvement.
- Unclear whether contractual limits prohibit third parties from reidentifying deidentified information.
And when they ask if there are advertisements or tracking, they say:
- Traditional or contextual advertisements are displayed.
- The vendor can send marketing messages.
- The vendor does provide promotional sweepstakes, contests, or surveys.
- Users can opt out of traditional, contextual, or behavioral advertising. [should be opt-in for student advertising]
- Users can opt out or unsubscribe from marketing communications. [should be opt-in for student advertising]
What about the other Cookies and Trackers still on the Zoom for Education page?
Remember when on the Zoom for Education webpage, you will see a pop up box asking if you want to opt out of third parties using your information–we said DON’T IGNORE THIS WHEN YOU SEE IT. These are the cookie settings you see today when you click More Info and Advanced Settings, and View Cookies.
Notice (orange arrows added) that Functional Cookies are still automatically Opted-In and include third parties like Twitter and Vimeo, New Relic, Salesloft, Milward Brown Digital, Pardot, and PayPal.
Google (Google ads?) and Zoom cookies are required.
Clicking on Google Inc you see: “Google operates Google Ads, Display & Video 360, and Google Ad Manager. These services allow advertisers to plan, execute and analyze marketing programs with greater ease and efficiency, while enabling publishers to maximize their returns from online advertising. Note that you may see cookies placed by Google for advertising, including the opt out cookie, under the Google.com or DoubleClick.net domains. For more information, see https://policies.google.com/technologies/ads ”
Clicking on Zoom you see: “api.zoom.us, blog.zoom.us, connectnz.zoom.us, facebook.zoom.us, google.zoom.us, imauth.zoom.us, investors.zoom.us, launcher.zoom.us, log.zoom.us, recurly-callout.zoom.us, support.zoom.us, www3.zoom.us, www.zoom.us, zoom.us, zuora-callout.zoom.us”
If these screen captures above are too small for you to see, or too buried for you to find, here’s a quick little video of Zoom’s required and automatically opted-in cookies.
The Common Sense privacy evaluation does not mention that, as of March 31, 2020, Zoom is also a Common Sense partner in the Wide Open School initiative, as is Apple and Google. Bill and Melinda Gates and Google also fund the initiative (no mention of Zoom funding). As one commenter on Common Sense’s Ultimate Guide to Zoom stated, “This is a great article and covers some primary questions I have as a parent. Yet I can’t help wondering if this is a promoted post from Zoom!” I tend to agree. Better to be transparent and disclose any funding or endorsement or partnership when evaluating a product.
Also, the Wide Open School initiative, which is curated by Common Sense, is meant to encourage schools and parents to implement specific edtech programs during the COVID shift to remote learning. They make the following fine-print disclaimer:
A note on privacy
“While we have tried to favor sites that don’t require login, some do require registration. The provided resources include links to external websites or applications that are governed by their own privacy policies or information-collection practices, which may be substantially different from those of Common Sense. We encourage you to review the privacy policies and information-collection practices of any external websites and apps before using them with children. Many organizations have stepped up and made their resources free for kids during this critical time.”
Is Zoom for Education a K-12 School Service?
Colorado has a state law that requires contracted edtech (school service providers) to be transparent about the data elements they collect, how the data are used and to list every subcontractor who has access to the data. Zoom doesn’t think they need to comply with this transparency law because they claim, “Zoom is not a School Service and is exempt from the requirements of the law.” The Colorado Attorney General’s privacy office is investigating whether Zoom threatens student privacy; let’s hope the Attorney General enforces Colorado law and requires Zoom to be transparent about how they and their subcontractors and third party apps (with SDKs) use student data now… and since March 2020.
It sure seems like Zoom is a school service:
- with a dedicated K-12 Zoom for Education webpage,
- Zoom white papers, blogs and tutorials for K-12 teachers and students,
- Common Sense gave Zoom high ranks for clearly being labeled as serving a school purpose, “primarily used by, designed for, and marketed toward students in grades preK–12.”
- Zoom is a Wide Open School preK-12 online education resource and partner,
- schools are requiring students to use Zoom remotely and recording video sessions and transcripts, students are answering school related questions, turning in school work (These are education records under FERPA.),
- Zoom actually described itself as a “K-12 service” in its prior K-12 privacy policies
- For purposes of FERPA, Zoom is considered a “school official”
Zoom is being used as a service in thousands of schools nationwide.
It’s difficult to know if Zoom is a threat to student privacy since Zoom keeps changing its privacy policies and cookie tracking practices, and Zoom won’t answer transparency questions about how data elements are used and shared.
What (little things) you can do to protect your student on Zoom.
In March 2020 we wrote this piece advising parents and educators to seek alternatives to screen time, get outdoors, cover your camera when possible. If your school requires your student to use Zoom, ask your school if your student can keep their camera off. We would add to turn off (opt-out) of non-essential cookies when possible. If using your home computer or device, you can install free plug-ins like EFF’s privacy badger, Lightbeam, Ghostery, uBlockOrigin that will also alert you or block third party trackers. You can also use a web browser like Brave or Firefox that will block ads and spyware.
Honestly, as a mom, I think I speak for most parents when I say that Zoom for Education (and all the virtual learning companies) should be required to tell parents how their children’s voice and video and data are used, and should be required to let parents know who else has access to our kids’ information. These companies should not be allowed to exploit students for marketing and advertising. This pandemic is tough enough, the last thing parents need is worrying about a company profiling their student. Parents and teachers are just trying to survive and teach our kids.